When a new list of banned books comes out it is almost certain there will be multiple YAL books on it. A big controversy over young adult lit is that it covers many "dark" areas. The content includes rape, drugs, suicide, sex etc. These are the areas where many say it is simply inappropriate to have on a school's library shelf. So why are these books so popular with the age group it's intended for if they are so dark?
The biggest point is that these books hit the intended audience right were they are at. Teenagers can spot folks being fake and phony immediately. So if an author tries to beat around the bush with a subject they will know immediately. Why not just say it? These are the things that teenagers are dealing with on a sometimes daily basis. YAL is dark at times but that is how real life is. These books might give more comfort than pain to those who are dealing with these issues. They might receive the message that they are not alone in their fight. It's human nature to feel comforted knowing we are not the only ones who struggle with a certain issue.
If we as educators only take a look at the darkness presented in these books we might be removing the potential positive impact these books could have on their readers. I think of the book, Some Assembly Required, and how the brave story of Arin has the chance to inspire others like him. If this book is banned in school libraries due to the content, it loses it's value to the world. I am sure Arin would have benefited greatly from having a book like this when he was younger to relate to. I question the folks who sit on the boards and ban these books and wonder if they have lost touch with their adolescent self.
Crystal,
ReplyDeleteIt is surprising to some people how others can read them like a book, without even knowing much about them. They are like what Megan said, good lie detectors. (great example btw) I think that kids need to know that they are not alone, so when these books get banned, where can a child go if they've utilized all resources available to them? I think banning books are hiding true life experiences that young adults can relate to. Why do this?
I agree, Crystal. But it is a hard sell for many parents who would like to believe their children are angels sent from heaven above and do nothing wrong. Ever. I think that is where educators get the feeling that books are not "appropriate" for our bookshelves. At least, that is what comes to my mind when I buy books for my future classroom. I try to ask myself, "How many parents will I get a phone call from if they see their child reading this book?" It's usually a pretty good indicator. I'll just send them to the public library, and their parents can call and complain there.
ReplyDeleteI think it would be very hard to have to deal with the repercussions from the parents. Maybe if some of the banned books were placed in a classroom library and were not class lead it would change it?
Delete